Interview: Ignacio Dinamarca — You Are Not Being Rejected, You Are Being Misread

32

Interview: Ignacio Dinamarca — You Are Not Being Rejected, You Are Being Misread

Former recruiter turned career coach Ignacio Dinamarca explains why most job seekers are not being rejected for who they are, but filtered on how they are read.

About Ignacio Dinamarca

Ignacio Dinamarca is a career coach based in Victoria, Canada, working with professionals across the United States and Canada. Trained as a metallurgical engineer in Chile, he moved into economics and then human resources, and taught at two Chilean universities before emigrating. In Canada he spent five years as an HR generalist and recruiter, hiring from entry level to C-suite. He has coached 400+ professionals over four years, spoke at DisruptHR Victoria 2024, and was named one of Victoria’s Top 15 Career Coaches in 2026.

What inspired you to become a coach, and how would you describe your coaching philosophy?

I had no plan to become a career coach. The demand arrived before the business did.

I had built a successful career in Canada as a newcomer, and people in my network could see it. Other immigrants started asking how I did it, and I kept saying yes. The requests did not stop, and eventually there were enough of them that it stopped being favours and started being a practice.

What made the help useful was the other half of my background. I was a recruiter. I had sat in the meetings where hiring decisions actually get made, and I knew the person on the other side would never be told what happened in that room. I could hand someone the missing piece and watch the whole thing move.

My philosophy has two halves that people assume are in tension. Most career coaching is encouragement. What people need is diagnosis. Feeling stuck is almost always a strategy problem, not a worth problem, and saying that plainly is more respectful than reassurance. The other half is that nobody changes anything in a room where they do not feel safe. I taught at two universities in Chile before this, and I still coach like an instructor: patient with the person, demanding about the work.

“Feeling stuck is almost always a strategy problem, not a worth problem.”

Could you share your journey and how those experiences shaped your approach?

I have made two full career pivots and one migration, and each one required giving up an identity I had invested years in.

I trained as a metallurgical engineer in Chile, moved into economics, and then into human resources. Then I moved to Canada with no family, no friends, no professional network, and a second language. First-generation immigrant, first-generation university graduate, no mentor, no roadmap. I figured most of it out by trial and error, which is an expensive way to learn anything.

What I built from that position is the proof that it is possible: a network of 1,000+ HR professionals across Canada, starting from zero contacts; five years as a generalist and recruiter in Canada, hiring from entry level to C-suite; a talk at DisruptHR Victoria 2024 to 400+ business owners and HR leaders; and recognition as one of Victoria’s Top 15 Career Coaches in 2026. Today I work with professionals across the United States and Canada.

That history shapes four things about how I coach.

  • I believe my clients, and then I tell them the truth. I know what it feels like to do everything right and get nothing back, so I do not treat frustration as a bad attitude. I also do not let anyone stay there.
  • I normalise deciding without certainty, because waiting for the right answer is what keeps most people frozen.
  • I bring an engineer’s structure to an emotional process. Career change feels chaotic, and it is actually diagnosable.
  • I do not romanticise the immigrant experience, or pity it. I know which parts are unfair, which are fixable, and which are the cost of entry. That produces advice people can act on instead of validation they cannot use.

 

What key elements does your coaching program include, and how do you help clients achieve meaningful outcomes?

Almost everyone arrives asking for a resume rewrite. That is a symptom-level fix, so it is never where we start.

Someone who has sent 300 applications has 300 data points and has usually never looked at one. Getting no interviews at all and losing in final rounds feel identical from the inside. They are different problems with different fixes, and most people spend months on the wrong one.

My process runs in five phases:

  1. Diagnose: a structured audit that names the actual failure point, in writing.
  2. Define: target and positioning. This is the hardest step emotionally, because focus feels like closing doors.
  3. Design: resume, LinkedIn and spoken pitch rebuilt as one coherent argument rather than three documents.
  4. Deploy: structured outreach with weekly targets, because a search that is 90% online applications is likely to fail no matter how good the resume is.
  5. Deliver: interview preparation, mock rounds under pressure, and negotiation through to a signed offer.

I have coached 400+ professionals over four years, through 1:1 and group sessions. Clients have landed roles at Walmart, Staples, KPMG, Deloitte, Samsung, Ford, Magna and Scotiabank.

“Someone who has sent 300 applications has 300 data points and has usually never looked at one.”

Why do you believe ongoing learning and education are essential for coaches?

I will give the unpopular version of this answer.

The risk in our profession is not that coaches stop learning. It is that we keep teaching the market that worked for us. Someone who ran a successful search in 2019 and has not been close to hiring since is giving advice calibrated to a market that no longer exists, and they will give it with total confidence, because it worked once.

Credentials matter. They establish a floor, and they protect clients from people operating on instinct alone. But a certificate tells you what was true when the curriculum was written. The job market has changed more in the last three years than any of my designations did, and nothing in a course would have told me how the volume of AI-generated applications has changed what employers trust.

So the learning that actually matters for a career coach is staying close to the hiring side: talking to recruiters who are screening this month, tracking outcomes across your own clients, and noticing when something that used to work stops working.

Formal education gives you frameworks. Proximity to the market keeps those frameworks honest. A coach who has one without the other is either theoretical or out of date.

“Formal education gives you frameworks. Proximity to the market keeps those frameworks honest.”

Is there a final thought you would like to leave our readers with?

If you are qualified, applying consistently, and getting nothing back, the thing to understand is that you are not being rejected for who you are. You are being filtered on how you are being read, and those are entirely different problems.

That distinction matters because of what people do with the first one. They conclude something is wrong with them, they shrink what they say about their own work, and they describe something they led as something they supported.

The hardest version of this is the advice newcomers receive constantly: start at the bottom and work your way back up. It sounds like humility, and it is the most expensive advice in the market. The entry-level role becomes your most recent role, which is the first thing anyone reads, and within a year or two it stops looking like a step and starts describing you. People are told to be patient, and patience quietly becomes the ceiling.

None of that is permanent. It is positioning, and positioning is learnable. The clients who get unstuck are rarely the most credentialed. They are the ones willing to find out what is actually happening, and then change one thing at a time until it does.

“You are not being rejected for who you are. You are being filtered on how you are being read.”

To learn more about Ignacio Dinamarca and his work, visit his LinkedIn profile.





Related Posts