Top 15 Pizza Places in New York City


Top 15 Pizza Places in New York City

New York’s pizzerias are iconic culinary destinations renowned for their diverse offerings and rich flavors. From traditional, family-owned establishments to trendy, artisanal spots, these pizzerias cater to a wide range of tastes and preferences. Characterized by their thin crusts, generous toppings, and unmistakable New York flair, these eateries offer a slice of the city’s vibrant culinary scene. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese slice or a gourmet pie with innovative toppings, New York’s pizzerias have something to satisfy every craving. Let’s take a look at the Top 15 Pizza Places in New York City.

Don’t miss our article if your around town, Top 15 Rooftops in New York City


Joe’s Pizza

Establishing its legacy in 1975, Joe’s Pizza, born from the culinary expertise of Neapolitan Joe Pozzuoli, has become synonymous with New York’s stereotypical street-style pizza. Nestled in Greenwich Village, it’s adored by locals and tourists alike for its authentic flavors perfected over 47 years.
With four locations across the city, Joe’s Pizza is a cherished emblem of New York’s culinary heritage. It embodies true Italian culture and has become a vital part of the city’s history.


Recommended: Caprese

Average price per person: $1 – 20 USD

Address: 1435 Broadway, New York, NY (Check out other locations)






NY Pizza Suprema

NY Pizza Suprema, owned by the same Italian family for over 45 years, isn’t just another spot on the bustling New York dining scene. Here, pizza takes center stage, representing not only the menu but the heart and soul of the establishment.
This beloved neighborhood joint, known for its old-school charm, serves up excellent slices crafted with the finest ingredients, making it a cherished favorite among locals.

Recommended: Fra Diavolo

Average price per person: $10 – 20 USD

Address: 413 8th Ave, New York, NY






Bleecker Street Pizza

Establishing its presence in 2004, Bleecker Street Pizza has earned a distinguished reputation as one of the leading pizzerias in the Upper Manhattan area. Recognized for consistently delivering delectable pizzas, the establishment prides itself on using only the finest dough, flavorful sauce, and authentic ingredients.
Bleecker Street Pizza is committed to providing customers with a warm and inviting atmosphere in which to savor their culinary creations.


Recommended: Sicilian Slice

Average price per person: $1 – 15 USD

Address: 69 7th Ave S, New York, NY








Nestled in the heart of Nolita, Rubirosa is a cherished Italian-American eatery and pizzeria established in 2009 under the guidance of AJ Pappalardo.
Operated by a close-knit family, the restaurant radiates a cozy and inviting ambiance, ideal for a variety of occasions, from communal family-style dinners to relaxed evenings spent indulging in aperitivo and antipasti at the intimate bar area.


Recommended: Tie-Dye Pizza

Average price per person: $30 – 50 USD

Address: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY





Juliana’s Pizza

In 2012, Pasquale Grimaldi opened a cozy pizza spot affectionately named after his mom. Drawing inspiration from family recipes and a deep love for real Italian food, it quickly became a local favorite.
Over time, Juliana’s Pizza gained more and more fans. By 2015, it received a special award from TripAdvisor, a well-known website where people share their travel experiences, and was named the best pizza place in the entire United States.


Recommended: Classic Margherita Pizza

Average price per person: $20 – 40 USD

Address: 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY






Champion Pizza

Champion Pizza prioritizes customer satisfaction by ensuring top-notch service and delicious food. They are committed to using the finest fresh ingredients in their recipes, including grandma’s pizzas and square pies, catering to various tastes.
To maintain quality, essential components like crust, sauce, and select toppings are made daily at their factories and delivered fresh to each store. This dedication to freshness and quality guarantees a consistent dining experience for customers at every visit.


Recommended: Truffled Mac N Cheese Pizza

Average price per person: $1 – 25 USD

Address: 17 Cleveland Pl, New York, NY (Check out other locations)





Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

Vezzo, nestled in a cozy neighborhood setting, takes pride in being a member of the esteemed Gruppo Thin Crust Pizza, established by Antonio Gomez. Renowned for its remarkably thin crust, often hailed as the thinnest of the thin, Vezzo guarantees a premium menu experience for its guests.
Indulge in gourmet thin-crust pizzas adorned with unique house toppings. Furthermore, Vezzo boasts a wine bar and offers a delectable brunch menu, ensuring a memorable dining affair for all.


Recommended: Shroomtown Pizza

Average price per person: $10 – 30 USD

Address: 178 Lexington Ave, New York, NY (Check out other locations)


















Prince Street Pizza

Devoted to spreading happiness with each slice, Prince Street Pizza holds a strong heritage in Sicilian recipes cherished across generations. Their sauces, handcrafted from scratch daily, perfectly complement their airy and crisp dough.
Beyond their culinary mastery, Prince Street Pizza is committed to creating a welcoming and comforting atmosphere in their stores, embracing all patrons warmly.


Recommended: Spicy Vodka Pizza

Average price per person: $1 -15 USD

Address: 27 Prince St A, New York, NY
















John’s Pizzeria of Times Square

Set within a 19th-century church transformed into an Italian dining destination, John’s of Times Square has earned acclaim as one of New York’s top pizza spots, renowned for its distinctive qualities. Pizzas are carefully prepared to order in one of the four coal-fired brick ovens, skillfully manned by experienced pizza artisans.
This commitment to tradition and excellence guarantees that each pie served at John’s of Times Square is a culinary masterpiece.


Recommended: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Average price per person: $25 – 40 USD

Address: 260 W 44th St, New York, NY

















Scarr’s Pizza

Scarr’s Pizza, established in 2016 by Scarr Pimentel, aims to recreate the nostalgic ambiance of neighborhood pizzerias from the 1970s or 1980s by sourcing much of its decor from a bowling alley. With wood-paneled walls and letter boards adding to the atmosphere, it’s a true throwback experience.
While serving classic New York pizza made with organic and fresh ingredients, dining at Scarr’s Pizza promises to be an unforgettable journey for your taste buds.


Recommended: Sicilian Slice

Average price per person: $1 – 15 USD

Address: 35 Orchard St, New York, NY
















Nolita Pizza

At Nolita Pizza, indulge in a gastronomic tour of Italy’s finest cuisine, allowing every bite to transport you to the heart of authentic Italian culinary excellence. Their dishes are meticulously crafted with the finest ingredients, promising an unparalleled taste experience.
With its unmistakable thin and crispy crust, Nolita Pizza invites you to enjoy a dining adventure you won’t soon forget. Moreover, their high-quality services and comfortable atmosphere, ensure a memorable dining experience for all.


Recommended: Pizza Bianca

Average price per person: $5 – 15 USD

Address: 68 Kenmare St, New York, NY


















Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY

Located at 70 Vanderbilt Ave., Uncle Paul’s Pizza NY has proudly served the people of New York with quality food, speedy delivery, and exceptional customer service for years. Their commitment to excellence extends to every aspect of the dining experience, from the delicious, typical NYC pizza slices they offer to the cozy and inviting atmosphere they provide.
They remain committed to offering affordable prices, ensuring that everyone can indulge in a satisfying dining experience.


Recommended: Lasagna Pizza

Average price per person: $5 – 20 USD

Address: 70 Vanderbilt Ave, New York, NY



















Little Italy Pizza

Since 1965, Little Italy Pizza has taken pride in providing customers with the highest standard of quality and service. Their NYC-style pizzeria offers a variety of slices, each boasting a taste that’s simply perfect and a must-try for everyone.
With multiple locations around the city, you can easily enjoy their delicious offerings. Their fast and friendly staff ensures a seamless dining experience, while their commitment to using only the freshest and finest ingredients guarantees that every bite is a true delight.


Recommended: Grandma Slice

Average price per person: $10 – 20 USD

Address: 2 E 33rd St, New York, NY (Check out other locations)



Little Italy

















Vinnie’s Pizzeria

Specializing in unique and creative cuisine, Vinnie’s Pizzeria expertly utilizes classic styles and ingredients while maintaining the original recipe unchanged. Each day, don’t miss out on their 2-3 new and unique daily specials featured on their Special Board.
Dining at Vinnie’s is more than just eating; it’s a true experience and a taste of tradition, where every bite reflects a dedication to culinary excellence passed down through generations.


Recommended: Mac N Cheese Pizza

Average price per person: $5 – 20 USD

Address: 148 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY

















Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza

Nestled in Brooklyn, New York, Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza stands out as a distinctive eatery. It offers thin-crust, brick-oven pizza alongside a gluten-free option and an array of other delectable dishes.
Prepared fresh to order in its wood-fired brick oven, Dellarocco’s pizzas are a culinary delight. With a warm and welcoming staff, a journey from Manhattan to experience Dellarocco’s is an absolute must.

Recommended: Neapolitan Style Pizza

Average price per person: $10 – 30 USD

Address: 214 Hicks St, Brooklyn, NY




















We hope you enjoyed our list of Top 15 Pizza Places in New York City!

Related Posts